PICK
New York Rangers ML -135

Anaheim Ducks vs New York Rangers Prediction: Best Bet for Monday

Madison Square Garden in New York, home of the Rangers
Madison Square Garden in New York, home of the Rangers. Photo: Richiekim, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
ANAHEIM DUCKS4-3-0
VS
NEW YORK RANGERS6-3-1
TOTAL
6.5
MONEYLINE
New York Rangers ML
Monday, October 19, 2026 · 6:00 PM CT · NHLMadison Square Gardenodds updated today

Anaheim Ducks (4-3-0) visits New York Rangers (6-3-1) on Monday. Our data-driven pick: New York Rangers ML.

01The Matchup

One perfect split ends at Madison Square Garden on Monday. The Rangers are 5-0-0 at home in the ESPN splits, the Ducks are 3-0-0 on the road, and the season numbers underneath those streaks explain why this projects as a tight, low-event game. New York is 6-3-1, scoring 2.80 and allowing 2.20 per game for a +0.60 differential. Anaheim is 4-3-0, scoring 3.14 and allowing 3.00 for a +0.14 differential.

Neither team generates much volume: the Rangers average 23.4 shots per game, the Ducks 24.1, the two lowest shot rates in this matchup set. When both teams play this structured, the game is usually decided by the one phase that is not close, and here that phase is special teams and defensive play, where New York holds clear edges.

02Key Factors

First, the penalty kill: New York kills 93.5 percent of penalties, and it runs directly into the one thing Anaheim does well, a power play converting 26.9 percent. If the Rangers' kill travels the way it has through ten games, the Ducks' best scoring route disappears.

Second, the defensive gap is 0.80 goals per game (2.20 allowed for New York, 3.00 for Anaheim), which matters in a low-shot game because Anaheim cannot simply create more attempts to compensate; at 24.1 shots per game, the volume is not there. Third, faceoffs tilt heavily to the home team, 53.8 percent for New York against 43.2 percent for Anaheim, the worst mark in this game. In a tight-checking game, starting with the puck after most draws is a steady, repeatable edge.

03The Pick

New York Rangers moneyline at -135. The differential gap is +0.46, well under the threshold this model needs for a puck line, so the honest play is the straight win rather than laying a goal and a half with a team scoring 2.80 per game. The case rests on specifics: a 2.20 goals-against average, a 93.5 percent penalty kill matched against Anaheim's 26.9 percent power play, a 53.8 to 43.2 faceoff edge, and a 5-0-0 home mark.

The caveat is real: Anaheim is 3-0-0 on the road and scores more per game (3.14) than New York does, so a Ducks win would not be a shock. But the Rangers defend, kill penalties, and win draws at rates the Ducks have not matched, and at home that profile is worth the -135 price. Rangers ML.

OUR VERDICT
New York Rangers ML -135

New York has a +0.46 goal differential edge per game, allows just 2.20 goals per game, and kills 93.5 percent of penalties against an Anaheim team winning 43.2 percent of faceoffs.

Interested in more NHL picks? Read our thoughts on who covers in Colorado Avalanche vs Philadelphia Flyers.

Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.