PICK
Utah Mammoth -1.5 +136

Pittsburgh Penguins vs Utah Mammoth Prediction: Best Bet for Monday

Delta Center in Salt Lake City, home of the Utah Mammoth
Delta Center in Salt Lake City, home of the Utah Mammoth. Photo: Tamanoeconomico, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
PITTSBURGH PENGUINS3-5-1
VS
UTAH MAMMOTH6-3-0
SPREAD
Utah Mammoth -1.5
TOTAL
6.5
MONEYLINE
Utah Mammoth ML
Monday, October 19, 2026 · 8:00 PM CT · NHLDelta Centerodds updated today

Pittsburgh Penguins (3-5-1) visits Utah Mammoth (6-3-0) on Monday. Our data-driven pick: Utah Mammoth -1.5.

01The Matchup

Utah's 6-3-0 start is built on controlling games rather than winning shootouts. The Mammoth score 3.67 and allow 3.00 per game for a +0.67 differential, and the shot data explains the control: 30.2 shots for and only 22.9 against per game, the best suppression number in any of Monday's games.

Pittsburgh is 3-5-1, scoring 3.11 and allowing 3.56 for a -0.44 differential, and the road has been the problem: the Penguins are 1-4-1 away from home in the ESPN splits, while Utah is 2-1-0 at the Delta Center. Pittsburgh's offense is good enough to keep this competitive, which is exactly why the margin question matters here: Utah does not need to outscore the Penguins in a track meet, it needs to keep Pittsburgh's chances scarce, and 22.9 shots allowed per game says that is its normal night.

02Key Factors

First, Utah's power play is the hottest unit on the Monday board at 35.3 percent, and Pittsburgh's penalty kill at 83.3 percent is solid but not built to erase a unit converting better than one chance in three. One extra power-play goal is often the whole puck-line margin. Second, shot suppression compounds that edge: Pittsburgh generates 28.3 shots per game against most teams, but Utah allows 22.9, so the Penguins' 3.11 goals per game are likely to be built on fewer looks than usual.

Third, the honest counterweight is Utah's own penalty kill at 73.3 percent, the weakest unit in this game. It is a real risk, softened by Pittsburgh's power play converting only 17.9 percent, but it is why this is a plus-price puck line and not a bigger bet. Faceoffs also favor Utah, 52.5 percent against 44.9 percent.

03The Pick

Utah Mammoth -1.5 at +136. The differential gap is +1.11, just past the puck-line threshold rather than comfortably beyond it, and the price reflects that. The supporting case is specific: a 35.3 percent power play against an 83.3 percent kill, 22.9 shots allowed per game against a road team that is 1-4-1 away and allows 3.56 goals per game, and a 52.5 to 44.9 faceoff edge that keeps Pittsburgh chasing.

The risk is named plainly: Utah's 73.3 percent penalty kill can give a goal back, and Pittsburgh scores 3.11 per game, so a 3-2 Utah win that misses the margin is a very live outcome. At +136, the combination of the league-hot power play and the best shot suppression on the slate is worth backing. Mammoth minus-1.5.

OUR VERDICT
Utah Mammoth -1.5 +136

Utah has a +1.11 goal differential edge per game, a 35.3 percent power play, and allows just 22.9 shots per game against a Pittsburgh team that is 1-4-1 on the road.

One more game on the board: our thoughts on who covers in Colorado Avalanche vs Philadelphia Flyers.

Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.