Columbus Blue Jackets vs New York Islanders Prediction: Best Bet for Tuesday

Columbus is 1-5-0 on the road and has lost four straight, scoring 2.39 goals per game, and Tuesday the Blue Jackets visit an Islanders team that just scored 11 goals in two road wins. The goaltending matchup may be the widest on the whole slate.
The Matchup
The Islanders are 9-6-4, scoring 3.11 goals per game and allowing 2.84, a +0.26 differential from a team that defends its way into most games. Bo Horvat leads New York with 9 goals, and Matthew Schaefer has 21 points on 6 goals and 15 assists from the blue line. New York lost three straight earlier this month, then answered with a 5-2 win at Los Angeles and a 6-2 win at Anaheim, the two best offensive nights of its season back to back.
Columbus is 7-11-0, scoring 2.39 per game and allowing 3.22, a -0.83 differential, and the road split explains the record: the Blue Jackets are 1-5-0 away from home. Kent Johnson leads Columbus with 18 points on 8 goals and 10 assists, and Zach Werenski has 13 assists. Columbus has lost four straight since a shootout win over Dallas, falling at Buffalo and then at home to Florida, Tampa Bay and Philadelphia, scoring one goal in two of those four losses.
Key Factors
The crease is where this game tilts hardest. Ilya Sorokin is the expected starter for New York at 2.53 goals against and a .915 save percentage, while Jet Greaves is the expected starter for Columbus at 3.42 and .875 with a 2-8 record. A Columbus offense scoring 2.39 a night has to solve the better goalie, and a Columbus defense allowing 3.22 has to protect the weaker one.
Sean Monahan is out tonight for Columbus with an upper body injury, which removes a top-six center from an offense that is already short on finish. Jean-Gabriel Pageau is day-to-day with a lower body injury for New York, and Logan Stanley is day-to-day with a lower body injury as well. Keep an eye on whether Pageau plays before placing a bet.
Special teams give Columbus no way back in. The Blue Jackets convert 18.2 percent on the power play against a New York kill of 85.9 percent, so their best route to a cheap goal runs into the Islanders' strongest unit. New York converts just 17.2 percent, but Columbus kills only 73.5 percent, so even a modest Islanders power play gets the friendlier matchup.
The Columbus case is Werenski driving play from the back and a young team playing loose with nothing to protect. It fails on the road record, the four straight losses, and a goaltending gap that shows up in almost every Columbus road game this season.
Columbus cannot score on the road, cannot protect its young goalie, and runs into the steadier team and the better netminder at UBS Arena. Take the New York Islanders moneyline at -142.
Game Information
| Date | Tuesday (11/17) |
|---|---|
| Start Time | 6:00 PM CT |
| How to Watch | NHL |
| Venue | UBS Arena |
| Total | 5.5 |
| Moneyline | New York Islanders -142 |
More Picks This Week
Player Props for This Game
2 props- Bo Horvat PointsOver 0.5 -150
- Kent Johnson PointsOver 0.5 -135
More on Columbus Blue Jackets and New York Islanders
NHL Props and Futures Boards
Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.