Indiana State Sycamores vs Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks Prediction, Odds, Best Bets - Week 3

INDIANA STATE SYCAMORES(2-2)
VS
STEPHEN F. AUSTIN LUMBERJACKS(3-1)
SPREAD
Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks -3.5
TOTAL
144.5
MONEYLINE
Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks -166 / Indiana State Sycamores +140
Friday (11/20) · 2:00 PM CT · ESPN+Elridge Blake Sports and Fitness Center, Charlotte Amalieodds at time of writing

Stephen F. Austin is 3-1 and has allowed 61.2 points a game, and Indiana State arrives in the Virgin Islands with Karmani Gregory averaging 21.3 points and an offense scoring 80.2 a game. One of these early season identities is about to crack.

The Matchup

Indiana State is 2-2, scoring 80.2 points a game and allowing 65.8, and the Sycamores' numbers come with a split personality. They routed Earlham 109 to 37 and beat Ball State 69 to 66, and they lost to Milwaukee 82 to 73 and Charlotte 78 to 70, so the good defensive work has come against the weaker half of the schedule.

Karmani Gregory is the whole show, averaging 21.3 points and 5.7 assists a game, and Duce Paschal leads the team at 7.0 rebounds a game, but the drop after Gregory is steep. Last season Indiana State scored 73.6 and allowed 74.5 on the way to an 11-21 finish in the Missouri Valley Conference, and blended across both seasons the Sycamores grade as a modestly positive team whose current numbers flatter it.

Stephen F. Austin is 3-1, scoring 90.8 points a game and allowing 61.2, and while the Lumberjacks have also fattened up on soft opponents, beating Lyon 120 to 61 and Texas Lutheran 89 to 32, they also beat Abilene Christian 76 to 71 in a real game and lost only to Rice, 81 to 78. Erik Makke leads the team at 16.0 points a game, Ashton Simmons adds 3.2 assists, and Edwin Daniel leads the team at 6.0 rebounds a game, a balanced profile with no single point of failure.

Last season Stephen F. Austin scored 76.4 and allowed 65.9 on the way to a 28-5 finish in the Southland Conference, and that full season of defensive proof is what separates this team from the other early season stat lines in this tournament. Blended across both seasons the Lumberjacks grade well ahead of Indiana State. Nobody on either roster carries an injury designation, and the game is on a neutral floor in Charlotte Amalie in the Virgin Islands.

Key Factors

This game is Gregory against a defense built to take away the one man an offense runs through. Stephen F. Austin allowed 65.9 points a game over a full 33 game season last year, not a five game burst, and the Lumberjacks can throw length at Gregory and live with whatever Indiana State's second and third options produce. The Sycamores' own defensive number, 65.8 allowed, was built on Earlham and Ball State, and Stephen F. Austin's balanced scoring, with Makke leading a group rather than carrying it, is much harder to scheme away.

The total is posted at 144.5, and the Lumberjacks' games have averaged about 152 points while Indiana State's have averaged about 146, so the scoring environment should be lively enough for a favorite to build a working margin. Simmons against Gregory at the point of attack is where the game will be decided, because if Gregory has to work for every touch, the Sycamores' half court offense runs late into the clock.

The honest counterpoint is that Gregory might simply be the best player on the floor by enough to matter. A guard averaging 21.3 points with 5.7 assists can win a neutral site game almost alone, and Stephen F. Austin's gaudy defensive numbers this season came against Lyon and Texas Lutheran, teams that tell us nothing. If Gregory gets downhill early and the Lumberjacks have to help, Indiana State's shooters get the clean looks that turn this into a coin flip late.

Our Pick
Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks -3.5-105

Stephen F. Austin defends at a level Indiana State has not seen this season, and the Lumberjacks have the deeper, more proven roster after a 28 win season a year ago. Gregory will get his points, but the Sycamores need a second source against this defense. Take Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks -3.5 at -105.

Score Projection
Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks 76, Indiana State Sycamores 68

Game Information

DateFriday (11/20)
Start Time2:00 PM CT
How to WatchESPN+
VenueElridge Blake Sports and Fitness Center, Charlotte Amalie
SpreadStephen F. Austin Lumberjacks -3.5
Total144.5
MoneylineStephen F. Austin Lumberjacks -166 / Indiana State Sycamores +140

Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.