Siena Saints vs St. John's Red Storm Prediction, Odds, Best Bets - Week 3

SIENA SAINTS(3-1)
VS
(#13)ST. JOHN'S RED STORM(4-0)
SPREAD
St. John's Red Storm -30.5
TOTAL
164.5
MONEYLINE
OFF
Wednesday (11/18) · 6:00 PM CT · truTVCarnesecca Arena, Queensodds at time of writing

St. John's is a huge home favorite over Siena at Carnesecca Arena, where Tim Ibukunoluwa averages 25.2 points and 11.2 rebounds per game for the visiting Saints.

The Matchup

Siena visits St. John's on Wednesday at 6:00 PM CT on truTV at Carnesecca Arena in Queens. Siena, from the Metro Conference, is 3-1 this season in 2026-27, scoring 83.8 points per game and allowing 77.8. St. John's, ranked (#13) and from the Big East Conference, is 4-0, scoring 87.8 points per game and allowing 62.2. St. John's is listed at -30.5 at -115, Siena at +30.5 at -105, with a total of 164.5 and no moneyline posted.

Last season both teams won plenty. Siena finished 23-12 last season, scoring 70.4 points per game and allowing 65.8, while St. John's finished 30-7, scoring 80.9 and allowing 69.6. This season Siena lost its opener 80-75 at Bryant, then beat Princeton 82-68, won 99-89 at Dayton and beat Brown 79-74. St. John's has been ruthless at home, beating Monmouth 78-63, Iona 104-65, Colgate 90-59 and Syracuse 79-62, with every win coming by at least 15 points in this building.

Tim Ibukunoluwa leads Siena at 25.2 points and 11.2 rebounds per game, with Pace Prosser adding 7.0 assists per game. Keyshawn Hall leads St. John's at 18.5 points per game, Quinn Ellis adds 8.2 assists per game and Tounde Yessoufou adds 7.5 rebounds per game. The early contrast is fascinating.

Siena has a single dominant player producing at a huge rate, while St. John's spreads the work across Hall, Ellis and Yessoufou and still wins every game comfortably. Siena also arrives with real road proof, having already won at Dayton in a high scoring game and pushed Bryant to a five point game on the road to open the season.

Key Factors

Ibukunoluwa has to keep producing against a Big East defense. He averages 25.2 points and 11.2 rebounds per game, numbers that would lead almost any team in the country, and Siena's cover hopes run through him scoring, rebounding and drawing fouls. St. John's allows only 62.2 points per game this season, so Siena cannot expect the 99 points it scored at Dayton. If Ibukunoluwa is held near half his scoring average, Siena has no second option proven at that level.

The total of 164.5 turns on the pace St. John's chooses. The teams combine to average 171.6 points scored per game this season, above the total, but St. John's also held Syracuse to 62 points and Colgate to 59. With a huge lead, the Red Storm often slow down, empty the bench and let the final minutes drift, which is exactly how a favorite wins easily without covering a number this large. Siena's own defense, allowing 77.8 points per game, has to survive the first wave.

The counterpoint is that St. John's might simply be that much better. The Red Storm beat Iona by 39 points and Colgate by 31 points at home, Hall and Ellis give them scoring and creation at 18.5 points and 8.2 assists per game, and Siena lost at Bryant to open the season. If St. John's presses early, forces turnovers and builds a twenty point lead before halftime, Siena chasing the game plays into the favorite's hands and the blowout cover becomes very real.

Our Pick
Siena Saints +30.5-105

St. John's is the better team by a wide distance, and Carnesecca Arena is a tough place for a visiting team to settle in. But this price asks the Red Storm to win by a huge amount and keep pushing long after the game is decided. Siena has a dominant big man who can score and rebound against anyone, and that gives the Saints a way to keep possessions competitive and avoid a complete runaway. Take Siena Saints +30.5 at -105.

Final Result
Siena Saints 72, St. John's Red Storm 119
Our pick Siena Saints +30.5 lost.
Score Projection
St. John's Red Storm 88, Siena Saints 77

Game Information

DateWednesday (11/18)
Start Time6:00 PM CT
How to WatchtruTV
VenueCarnesecca Arena, Queens
SpreadSt. John's Red Storm -30.5
Total164.5
MoneylineOFF

Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.