St. John's Red Storm vs Oklahoma State Cowgirls Prediction, Odds, Best Bets - Week 3

ST. JOHN'S RED STORM(4-0)
VS
(#25)OKLAHOMA STATE COWGIRLS(4-1)
SPREAD
Oklahoma State Cowgirls -7.5
TOTAL
136.5
MONEYLINE
Oklahoma State Cowgirls -355
Wednesday (11/18) · 6:30 PM CT · ESPN+Gallagher-Iba Arena, Stillwaterodds at time of writing
Inside Gallagher-Iba Arena in Stillwater
Inside Gallagher-Iba Arena in Stillwater. Photo: Ash Lux, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

No. 25 Oklahoma State is 4-1 and unbeaten at home. St. John's is 4-0 and has not allowed 53 points in a game, and the Red Storm take their defense on the road for the first time as a 7.5-point underdog in Stillwater.

The Matchup

Oklahoma State is 4-1 and ranked No. 25, and the Cowgirls have been hard to guard. They beat Southern 81-39, Morgan State 92-38 and Northwestern State 94-56 at home, then won 90-80 at South Dakota State on Sunday, scoring 83.8 points per game and allowing 55.4 this season. Liv McGill leads Oklahoma State at 20.2 points and 7.2 assists per game, and Stailee Heard pulls 7.0 rebounds a night. McGill and Heard carry no injury designations for Wednesday.

St. John's is 4-0, and the Red Storm have won with defense. They beat Lafayette 95-37, Wagner 102-33, Quinnipiac 73-52 and Rhode Island 68-51, all at home, scoring 84.5 points per game and allowing 43.3. Ny'Ceara Pryor leads St. John's at 15.0 points and 6.2 assists per game, and Daniela Abies pulls 7.0 rebounds a night. Pryor and Abies carry no injury designations for Wednesday.

Four and five games is a thin file, so last season still shapes these numbers, and last season pulls the two programs closer than this month's scores suggest. Oklahoma State went 24-10, scoring 81.1 points per game and allowing 64.2, while St. John's went 22-12 in the Big East, scoring 61.4 and allowing 61.2. Put the two seasons together and Oklahoma State scores 82.4 points per game and allows 59.8, against St. John's at 72.9 scored and 52.2 allowed.

The honest catch sits on the St. John's side of that math: the Red Storm's jump from 61.4 points a game to 84.5 has come at home against Lafayette, Wagner, Quinnipiac and Rhode Island, and Wednesday is their first road game of the season, against the best team they have faced. DraftKings makes Oklahoma State a 7.5-point favorite at Gallagher-Iba Arena, with a total of 136.5 and Oklahoma State at -355 on the moneyline.

Key Factors

The St. John's defense is the one thing in this game that has shown up every night. Four opponents have scored 37, 33, 52 and 51 points against the Red Storm. That slate was soft, and Oklahoma State's guards are a different test, but a team allowing 43.3 points a game does not need to shoot well on the road to stay in a game.

It needs its defense to travel, and a defense built on half-court discipline usually does. Pryor matters here on both ends: she leads St. John's in scoring and assists, and her 6.2 assists a night against 15.0 points scored says the Red Storm's offense runs through a guard who shares the ball rather than one who hunts shots.

Oklahoma State's offense runs through McGill more than the scoring balance suggests. McGill leads the Cowgirls at 20.2 points and 7.2 assists per game, which means she is creating most of what Oklahoma State scores. When she plays well early, the Cowgirls have buried teams in this building, winning their three home games by 42, 54 and 38 points.

When a visitor slows the game down, the margin compresses fast: Tulsa held Oklahoma State to 62 points and won by 2, and South Dakota State scored 80 and stayed within 10 on Sunday. St. John's does not need to stop McGill. It needs to make her work for her points across forty minutes, because Oklahoma State's cover path runs through her efficiency.

The counterpoint is the step up in class, and it is a real one. St. John's has not left home, has not faced a ranked team, and has not seen an athlete like McGill. Gallagher-Iba Arena is loud, Oklahoma State is 3-0 in the building, and a Red Storm offense that lived comfortably against Wagner and Quinnipiac can look very different when a Big 12 defense takes away the first option.

If Oklahoma State speeds Pryor up early and the crowd gets into the game, this spread is short. The case for the points is narrower and simpler: St. John's defends at a level that keeps games low and close, the two-season numbers put these teams within a few points of each other, and 7.5 points is a real cushion against a defense that has not allowed 53 points in a game all season.

Our Pick
St. John's Red Storm +7.5-110

Oklahoma State is ranked, unbeaten at home, and the Cowgirls should win this game. But St. John's defends well enough to make a favorite work for every basket, Pryor gives the Red Storm a guard who can settle a road game late, and an unbeaten team catching points with that defense does not need much to go right to stay close. Take the points with St. John's Red Storm +7.5 at -110.

Final Result
St. John's Red Storm 63, Oklahoma State Cowgirls 77
Our pick St. John's Red Storm +7.5 lost.
Score Projection
St. John's Red Storm 66, Oklahoma State Cowgirls 70

Game Information

DateWednesday (11/18)
Start Time6:30 PM CT
How to WatchESPN+
VenueGallagher-Iba Arena, Stillwater
SpreadOklahoma State Cowgirls -7.5
Total136.5
MoneylineOklahoma State Cowgirls -355

Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.