Troy Trojans vs Nicholls Colonels Prediction, Odds, Best Bets - Week 4
Troy is favored on a neutral floor in Pensacola despite a defense that has leaked points all month, and Nicholls has the better playmaker in the game. Sheridan Sharp runs the Colonels' offense, and the Trojans have to prove they can guard for forty minutes.
The Matchup
Troy and Nicholls meet Sunday at Pensacola Bay Center in Pensacola, a neutral floor, with Troy listed as a 5.5-point favorite, a total of 134.5, and the Trojans at -225 on the moneyline. Troy is 2-3. Nicholls is 2-4. Both teams are playing their second game at this event, and both arrive with questions that the price mostly asks of only one side.
Troy scores 69.6 points a game and allows 77.2, and the defense is the story of its season so far. The Trojans beat Loyola Marymount 74-69 at home, lost 81-62 at NC State and beat Cal State Northridge 84-74 in their last three games, scoring enough to win twice while defending well in neither victory.
Donovan Oday leads Troy at 14.8 points and 6.2 rebounds a game, and Jacoi Hutchinson adds 4.0 assists a game. Oday is a genuine two-way piece, but the Trojans around him have not stopped anyone, and a team allowing 77.2 a night has to outscore its problems.
Nicholls scores 69.5 points a game and allows 71.2, a steadier profile than its record suggests. The Colonels beat Louisiana Tech 71-68 at home, lost 76-41 at Ole Miss and lost 80-69 to Southern Miss on a neutral floor on Saturday.
Doyel Cockrill III leads Nicholls at 12.6 points a game, Sheridan Sharp adds 5.2 assists a game, and AJ Dent leads the Colonels at 6.2 rebounds a game. Sharp is the best pure playmaker in this game, and the Ole Miss loss is the one true no-show on a schedule that has asked a lot of this team.
Five and six games into the season, these margins still lean on last season, and the specifics flatter Troy less than the price does. The Trojans outscored their opponents by 7.2 points a game last season on a strong year, while Nicholls was outscored by 2.5, so the historical gap is real. This season has moved the other way: Troy's defense has fallen apart against a mixed schedule, and Nicholls has been the steadier team night to night. Neither team carries an injury designation into this game.
Key Factors
Sharp against the Troy defense is where this game tilts. A point guard handing out 5.2 assists a game against a defense allowing 77.2 points a night is a recipe for open looks, and Cockrill is a good enough scorer to punish a defense that has to help. Troy's path runs through Oday at both ends, and asking one player to lead the team in scoring and rebounding while chasing Sharp's actions is a heavy afternoon.
The setting helps the underdog more than the favorite. Pensacola is a neutral floor, so Troy gets no home comforts, and both teams played here on Saturday, which levels the familiarity. These teams score a combined 139.1 points a game against a total of 134.5, so a moderately paced game is expected, and in that kind of game a 5.5-point spread asks the favorite to be clearly better for forty minutes. Nothing in Troy's defensive form this month supports that ask.
The honest counterpoint is last season's gap and Troy's higher ceiling. The Trojans were the far better program a year ago, Oday is the best player on the floor, and Nicholls scored 41 points at Ole Miss when its offense broke down completely. If Troy's defense shows up the way it did in stretches against Loyola Marymount, the favorite wins this by double digits. The pick rests on Sharp, the neutral floor and a Troy defense that has not earned this kind of trust yet.
Nicholls has the better playmaker in Sheridan Sharp, a real scorer in Doyel Cockrill III, and none of the travel disadvantage Troy might expect on a neutral floor in Pensacola. Troy has been shaky defensively all month, and this sets up as a one-possession game late. Take Nicholls Colonels +5.5 at -108.
Game Information
| Date | Sunday (11/22) |
|---|---|
| Start Time | 2:00 PM CT |
| How to Watch | YouTube |
| Venue | Pensacola Bay Center, Pensacola |
| Spread | TROY -5.5 |
| Total | 134.5 |
| Moneyline | Troy Trojans -225 |
More Picks This Week
More on Troy Trojans and Nicholls Colonels
NCAAM Props and Futures Boards
Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.