William & Mary Tribe vs Youngstown State Penguins Prediction, Odds, Best Bets - Week 4
William & Mary brings one of the highest-scoring offenses in the country to Youngstown, where the Penguins have allowed 82.6 points a game and just gave up 91 at Cincinnati. Brian Carter Jr. leads a Tribe attack that has topped 77 points in every game but one.
The Matchup
William & Mary and Youngstown State meet Sunday at Zidian Family Arena at Beeghly Center in Youngstown, with William & Mary listed as a 2.5-point road favorite, a total of 166.5, and the Tribe at -135 on the moneyline. William & Mary is 4-2. Youngstown State is 2-3. A road favorite in a high-total game usually means the visitors can really score, and that is the case here.
William & Mary is scoring 85.8 points a game and allowing 78.2 in the Coastal Athletic Association, and the Tribe offense travels. William & Mary scored 79 in a loss at Michigan, beat Bowling Green 77-73, and beat Averett 85-39 in its last game.
Brian Carter Jr. leads the Tribe at 16.5 points and 4.0 assists a game, and Jesse McIntosh adds 4.7 rebounds a game. The Michigan loss, 123-79, is the blemish, but that is a top team playing at full speed. Against comparable competition, this offense has been steady all month.
Youngstown State is scoring 70.0 points a game and allowing 82.6 in the Horizon League, and the Penguins' defense is the story of their start. Youngstown State lost 91-78 at Central Michigan, beat Marshall 74-71 at home, and lost 91-54 at Cincinnati in its last game.
Jaiden Haynes leads the Penguins at only 11.2 points a game, Dom Aekins adds 4.6 assists a game, and Kelvin Amoako leads Youngstown State at 6.4 rebounds a game. A leading scorer at 11.2 points a night means the offense has no one to lean on when a game speeds up, and this game will speed up.
Six and five games into the season, the margins still lean on last season, and last season backs the road team. William & Mary outscored its opponents by 5.4 points a game last season and won twenty games doing it, so this offensive identity is established. Youngstown State outscored its opponents by 4.9 a game last season, but this season's version has already allowed 91 twice in five games, which is a defensive drop-off the Penguins have not explained. Neither team carries an injury designation into this game.
Key Factors
The total of 166.5 is enormous, and it is honest. William & Mary games have produced 164.0 points a night and Youngstown State games 152.6, and both defenses allow opponents to play at full speed. A shootout favors the team with the better shooters and the clearer lead scorer, and Carter against a Penguins defense allowing 82.6 a night is the best individual matchup in this game.
The home floor is Youngstown State's real argument. The Penguins beat Marshall in this building, Beeghly Center is a tough small gym, and William & Mary is playing its second true road game against a Division I opponent after the Michigan trip went badly. If the Penguins slow the first ten minutes down and keep the crowd in it, a short road favorite can get uncomfortable fast.
The honest counterpoint is that William & Mary's own defense allows 78.2 points a game, so the Penguins will get their chances, and Haynes and Aekins have both had better games than their averages suggest. A hot home shooting night makes this a coin flip late. The pick rests on the gap in offensive reliability: the Tribe score in the high seventies or better almost every night, and the Penguins have two losses by thirteen or more already.
William & Mary scores too well for a Youngstown State team that has already given up big numbers twice and has no clear lead scorer to answer with. The Tribe are the better offensive team even on the road, and this price asks them only to win the game. Take William & Mary Tribe -135.
Game Information
| Date | Sunday (11/22) |
|---|---|
| Start Time | 1:00 PM CT |
| How to Watch | ESPN+ |
| Venue | Zidian Family Arena at Beeghly Center, Youngstown |
| Spread | W&M -2.5 |
| Total | 166.5 |
| Moneyline | William & Mary Tribe -135 |
More Picks This Week
More on William & Mary Tribe and Youngstown State Penguins
NCAAM Props and Futures Boards
Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.