St. Thomas Tommies vs Long Island University Sharks Prediction, Odds, Best Bets - Week 3

ST. THOMAS TOMMIES(2-3)
VS
LONG ISLAND UNIVERSITY SHARKS(0-5)
SPREAD
St. Thomas Tommies -2.5
TOTAL
149.5
MONEYLINE
OFF
Monday (11/16) · 6:00 PM CT · NEC Front RowBrooklyn Athletic Center, Brooklynodds at time of writing
SpreadSTMN -2.5
Total149.5
MoneylineOFF

St. Thomas is a short road favorite in Brooklyn against a Long Island team that has lost all five games and owns the weakest offense in this matchup by a wide margin.

The Matchup

Long Island is 0-5, and the problem is easy to find: the Sharks score 60.8 points per game, the lowest mark of any team on Monday's slate. They lost at Towson 66-46 and at Fordham 80-58, and their best offensive night of the last three was 80 in a loss at La Salle. Daquan Davis leads Long Island at 12.6 points per game, Vasean Allette adds 5.6 assists per game, and Ryan Bewley leads the Sharks on the glass at 6.2 rebounds per game.

St. Thomas comes to Brooklyn at 2-3 with a very different profile. The Tommies score 82.4 points per game, hung 119 on Macalester on November 12, and lost to Army 79-77 on November 14 in a game that was theirs to take. Hayden Tibbits leads St. Thomas at 16.2 points and 4.6 assists per game, and Jeremy Lorenz adds 6.4 rebounds per game. The Tommies allow 78.2 points per game, so their games are open and high-event, which suits the better offensive team.

Road favorites in small gyms deserve a pause, and the Brooklyn Athletic Center will be loud for a winless team hunting its first victory. But the season's shape is hard to argue with: St. Thomas was the stronger team across last season as well, outscoring its opponents by double digits per game over the full year, while Long Island's current slide follows a solid season of its own, which makes the 0-5 start more about an offense that has lost its way than about a program in freefall. Even allowing for a bounce-back, the Sharks have to find 15 extra points from somewhere.

Key Factors

The scoring gap is the whole argument. St. Thomas puts up 82.4 points per game; Long Island puts up 60.8. The Sharks have scored 46, 58, and 80 in their last three games, and two of those three would leave them needing a defensive masterpiece to beat even a modest Tommies night. Tibbits is the engine of the gap: 16.2 points and 4.6 assists per game means he is creating or scoring a large share of everything St. Thomas does, and Long Island has nobody producing at that level.

Pace compounds it. St. Thomas wants the game in the 70s and 80s, where its extra possessions punish a team that cannot score. Long Island's path is to drag the game into the low 60s and hope, but a team allowing 75.0 points per game has not shown it can impose that kind of game on anyone, and the Sharks trailed Fordham by 22 and Towson by 20 doing exactly the opposite.

The counterpoint is St. Thomas's own defense and its road record. The Tommies allow 78.2 points per game, lost to Green Bay by 9, and needed everything to hang with Army. If Allette, at 5.6 assists per game, gets Long Island's shooters clean looks early and the Brooklyn crowd smells an upset, a short road favorite with a leaky defense can find itself in a one-possession game late. The pick trusts the 22-point scoring gap more than it fears that script.

Our Pick
St. Thomas Tommies -2.5-110

Long Island cannot score, and St. Thomas plays fast with the best player on the floor running its offense. A short road number is a fair price for the clearly better offensive team. Take St. Thomas Tommies -2.5 at -110.

Score Projection
Long Island University Sharks 72, St. Thomas Tommies 78

Game Information

DateMonday (11/16)
Start Time6:00 PM CT
How to WatchNEC Front Row
VenueBrooklyn Athletic Center, Brooklyn
SpreadSt. Thomas Tommies -2.5
Total149.5
MoneylineOFF

Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.