New York Islanders vs Ottawa Senators Prediction: Best Bet for Thursday

NEW YORK ISLANDERS3-3-0
VS
OTTAWA SENATORS5-2-0
TOTAL
5.5
MONEYLINE
New York Islanders ML
Thursday (10/15) · 6:00 PM CT · NHLCanadian Tire Centreodds at time of writing
Canadian Tire Centre in Ottawa, home of the Senators
Canadian Tire Centre in Ottawa, home of the Senators. Photo: Ontario Images, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

New York Islanders (3-3-0) visits Ottawa Senators (5-2-0) on Thursday. Our data-driven pick: New York Islanders ML.

The Matchup

Ottawa brings the better record into Canadian Tire Centre at 5-2-0, but the underlying numbers point the other way, and that tension is the whole game. The Islanders are 3-3-0 with a plus-0.67 differential, scoring 3.17 goals per game and allowing only 2.50. Ottawa scores 2.86 and allows 2.71 for a plus-0.14 differential, a winning record built on close games rather than control.

Ottawa also generates just 23.1 shots per game, the lowest output in this matchup, while the Islanders win 52.7 percent of faceoffs and start more shifts with possession. Records reward who finished tight games. Differentials describe who played them better, and through six and seven games those two stories disagree here.

Key Factors

First, the defensive gap: 2.50 goals allowed per game for the Islanders against 2.71 for Ottawa, paired with a scoring edge of 3.17 to 2.86, gives the visitors the better number at both ends. Second, special teams lean slightly to New York as well, with a 21.1 percent power play against Ottawa's 15.2 percent, and an 82.6 percent penalty kill against 78.6 percent.

Neither edge is huge, but both point the same way. Third, Ottawa's counter is real and simple: home ice, a 5-2-0 record, and a habit of winning the one-goal games the Islanders have split. If this stays tight into the third period, Ottawa's finishing in close games is the risk to the pick.

Our Pick
New York Islanders ML (+130)

New York Islanders moneyline at plus-130, and this is a lean, not a lock. The differential gap is minus-0.53 from Ottawa's side, meaning the model favors the road team by about half a goal per game, well short of puck-line territory. The case rests on the Islanders allowing 2.50 per game, scoring 3.17, and holding small edges on both special-teams units and at the faceoff dot at 52.7 percent.

The market and the standings both prefer Ottawa, which is why the price is plus money, and Ottawa's 5-2-0 mark is a fair warning that this team closes games. Take the plus price on the team with the better differential, but size it like the close call the numbers say it is.

Game information

DATEThursday (10/15)
START TIME6:00 PM CT
HOW TO WATCHNHL
VENUECanadian Tire Centre
TOTAL5.5
MONEYLINENew York Islanders ML

Player props for this game

4 props
  • Linus Ullmark SavesOver 22.5 -105
  • Bo Horvat Shots On GoalOver 2.5 -111
  • Matthew Schaefer Shots On GoalOver 2.5 -152
  • Shane Pinto PointsOver 0.5 +114
See all 4 prop cards for this game, with short analysis, on the NHL props page →

Every pick is published with its line before the game. Odds via consensus sportsbooks at time of writing and move constantly. Must be 21+. If gambling is a problem, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.